homemade nutter butter's

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

Okay, guys.  Go to your refrigerator, take out 2 cups of butter (I know!  That's a  lot of butter!) and get it to start the softening process.   You're gonna want to make these... quickly.  
My kids all used the exact same adjective.  At different times.  "Amazing."  I thought that was pretty much amazing, too.  
If you can dare to not taste the dough... all the power to you.  Just beware that once you DO taste it, you won't be able to stop with one spoon full.
They were a little more time consuming than my most baked cookie.  But, SO worth every minute.  
The recipe makes quite a bit.  So I popped half into the freezer for a later date.  
I also played around with the size.  The size I was happiest with was making the balls about the size of a small brussel sprout.  
You need to overemphasize the shaping part.  Really get in there and squeeze your peanut together.  
And get ready to have a batch of truly amazing cookies, that won't last long.  
Recipe here.  I only made half of the icing since I froze half of the dough.

I'll be back tomorrow with the winner of Sew Red.


You Might Also Like


  1. I so wish I had a few of these + a cold glass of milk, right this very moment.

  2. Those are some powerful cookie photos. My son just tried to lick the screen!

  3. Anonymous5/15/2013

    Just as easy to buy them.

  4. Oh, man. Looks amazing.

    I recently made a cake with two pounds of butter. The more butter, the better!

  5. Missy, I am going to make those just as soon as I get off my "I have my 25th college reunion and have to be skinny" diet next week. And I will eat the whole batch myself!

  6. They look yummy :-)

  7. Yum! These look delicious!!

  8. gah!!! i just bought some yesterday!! i would LOVE to make them with my kids!! can't wait!

  9. OH WOW......YOU are amazing :)

    LOVE. love, love your new header....ahhhhh....I can almost smell them!

  10. ooh, these look SO delicious!

  11. Those look like so much fun....and YUMMY!

  12. OMG - another one I'm going to have to try!

  13. Yep, I need these in my life!

  14. Thank you for another fantastic posting. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a speech next week, and I was looking for more info.
    www.giochi-delle-winx.com , juegosfrivol , friv2planet , friv400game